Methodology
How we pick, in plain language — and what we do not do.
What we are
Shortlist Home is a research-based buying guide. We do not run a lab and we do not do hands-on testing. We say so on every page, because a pick that was never tested should never be presented as if it was.
How a shortlist is built
- Shortlist the category. We gather the products buyers actually consider for one category, from manufacturer specs, retailer listings and public buyer feedback.
- Rank on verifiable facts. Specs that can be traced to a manufacturer or retailer source, public rating volume, and buyer mentions. A number we cannot source is left blank, never guessed.
- Four roles, four budgets. Top pick, upgrade, best value and premium. One of them fits most budgets; the rest cover the edges.
- Write the trade-offs. Every pick gets a “Skip if” and a trade-off. A recommendation without a downside is an ad, not advice.
- Check the price, show the date. Every price carries the date it was checked. Prices are re-checked on a schedule and after any merchant link change.
Multi-merchant comparison
Where a direct merchant price and an Amazon price both exist for the same product, both are shown. The direct merchant price often carries a higher commission for us; that never decides the ranking. Rankings are made before any commission is considered, and the same rule applies to every product.
What we never do
- Never invent a score, a rating, a sales figure, a discount or a “limited time” claim.
- Never present a spec we could not verify.
- Never pad a shortlist with near-identical SKUs to reach a round number. A category ships when it has solid picks, not before.
- Never sell a ranking. Brands cannot pay to appear on a shortlist or to move up one.
Prices and links
Prices change. A price shown here is the price on the date it was checked, and that date is printed next to it. If a merchant changes its store URL or tracking link, our link check flags it and the link is regenerated or removed — a dead link is worse than no link. Link checks run monthly, price checks run more often.
Corrections
If a price, spec or pick on this site is wrong, tell us through the contact page and we will fix it and note the correction.